Starters & Salads
Thick slice of Country Italian bread toasted with garlic butter by the slice.
Thick slice of Country Italian bread toasted with garlic butter and mozzarella
cheese by the slice.
Country Italian bread, sliced thick topped with our own seasoned tomatoes slightly
toasted, topped with parmesan cheese by the slice.
Basket of five oven baked bread sticks served with our made from scratch meat sauce.
Mixed greens garnished with red cabbage, carrots, cherry tomato, red onion and
croutons with your choice of dressing. (Ranch, French, Italian and Raspberry Vinaigrette)
Additional dressing $1.30.
Romaine and mixed greens with Tomato, Feta Cheese, Kalamata olives, red onion,
and cucumber with greek dressing.
|Chicken BLT Salad||$8.00|
Mixed greens garnished with bacon, cheddar cheese and raspberry vinaigrette.
Side of Ranch, Meat Sauce & Marinara 1.30
Savory homemade dressing and sauces are perfect for dipping.
|Chicken Caesar Salad||$8.00|
Romaine lettuce, sliced tender chicken breast, with shredded parmesan cheese,
and croutons all tossed in Caesar Dressing.
Our own unique twist on an Italian Classic, with crisp dough and a
special red sauce. Served with your choice of a side of ranch or marinara.
Marinara sauce, sausage, and onion
Marinara sauce, provolone cheese, cheddar cheese, and mozzarella cheese.
Marinara sauce, beef, sausage, pepperoni, canadian bacon, and mozzarella cheese.
Pesto sauce, pepperoni, onion, pepperoncini, tomato, and mozzarella cheese.
Marinara sauce, pepperoni, sausage, onion, green pepper, mushroom, and mozzarella cheese.
All pasta dinners served with Italian bread and a tossed salad. Pasta is served until 10:00 p.m.
A delicious combination of our made from scratch meat sauce and melted Mozzarella cheese.
Traditional Pasta topped with your choice of our made from scratch meat
sauce or marinara sauce.
Add two meatballs $3.00.
Layers of pasta with ricotta, mozzarella and our made from scratch meat sauce.
Fettuccine noodle with creamy Alfredo. Add chicken or shrimp $3.00.
Cheese-stuffed ravioli with your choice of our made from scratch meat sauce,
marinara, pesto or alfredo sauce.
Beef-stuffed Ravioli with your choice of rich meat sauce, pesto or alfredo sauce
4 Beef and 4 Cheese Ravioli with your choice of rich meat sauce, pesto or alfredo sauce
Cured ham, capocolla, salami, pepperoni and sliced provolone, piled high on a
hoagie bun with shredded lettuce and “hero” sauce.
Savory homemade meatballs topped with zesty marinara
sauce and provolone on a hoagie bun.
Italian sausage, onions, roasted peppers and provolone covered
with marinara sauce on a hoagie bun.
Marinated beef strips with onions, roasted sweet peppers, mushrooms and
provolone cheese on a toasted hoagie bun.
|Ham & Cheese||$8.00|
Each week, a Wisconsin dairy ships an exclusive, custom-made 100% mozzarella cheese to the Pagliai restaurants. This special blend, created according to Pagliai’s specifications and certified by the National Dairy Council, blends skim and whole milks. Preservative-free, lean Italian sausage is ground weekly using small seven-pound preferred cuts of pork roast, a succulent cut regularly chosen by home cooks. Pizza and spaghetti sauces are precise replicas of Mama and Papa Pagliai’s wholesome mixtures of tomatoes, onion, garlic and assorted spices right down to the last dash of oregano. Diners may discover a few other family secrets as they watch their own pizzas being prepared in open, easy-to-view kitchens and slid into stone hearth ovens.
Thin & Crispy Double Crust
(Our Specialty) (Thick & Crispy)
Sausage (made in our kitchen) • Shrimp Onion • Green Olives• Beef • Anchovy • Pepperoncini • Sauerkraut • Pepperoni • Fresh Garlic • Tomatoes • Pineapple • Bacon Bits • Fresh Spinach • Artichoke Hearts • Green Pepper • Canadian Bacon • Fresh Mushrooms • Black Olives • Roasted Red Pepper • Chicken • Pickles
No substitutions on Specialties.
|10″ 12″ 14″|
|Cheese Pizza||9.00 12.00 14.50|
|Additional Toppings, Double Crust, or 10″ Gluten Free Crust||1.55 1.75 2.00|
|Double Cheese . . . Double Your Pleasure!||1.60 1.90 2.20|
|Pagliai’s Special||12.45 16.00 19.00|
Sausage, green pepper, onion.
|House Special||14.00 17.50 21.00|
Sausage, beef, pepperoni, onion, green pepper, mushroom.
||14.30 17.60 21.50|
Beef, onion, taco chips, sour cream, lettuce, cheddar cheese.
|Vegetarian Pizza||13.00 16.25 20.00|
Marinated spinach, onion, green pepper, mushroom, tomatoes, light cheese.
|Margherita Pesto Pizza||14.20 17.50 21.00|
Pesto sauce, tomatoes, feta cheese, artichokes.
|Shrimp Alfredo Pizza||14.20 17.50 21.00|
Alfredo sauce, shrimp, onion, bacon, three cheeses.
|Pepperoni Pesto Pizza||14.20 17.50 21.00|
Pesto sauce, pepperoni, tomatoes, black olives, onion, feta cheese, pepperoncini.
|Bacon Cheeseburger Pizza||14.20 17.50 21.00|
Beef, red onion, bacon, pickles, cheddar cheese, pizza sauce.